Is Cole Palmer Underperforming or Just Unlucky?

Cole Palmer’s recent drop in goals and assists has raised questions about his form, yet advanced metrics suggest his underlying production remains steady despite the increased defensive attention from opponents.

Original Source
The Athletic
Written by
Steve Worrell
12 Feb
8:36
Analysis

The1905.Club Summary

Chelsea’s attacking midfielder Cole Palmer, once hailed as a Premier League breakout star with six goals and five assists in his first seven league appearances during the 2023‑24 season, has seen a noticeable decline in his direct contributions. Since the October international break, Palmer has scored eight goals (including two penalties) and provided only one assist in 17 league games, marking his longest goal- and assist-less stretch. Critics have pointed to his recent performance—especially during a string of matches where he created 32 chances in 11 games without registering an assist—as evidence of a potential regression. However, detailed analysis shows that when penalties are excluded, his scoring rate and non-penalty expected goals (npxG) per 90 minutes have remained consistent with his breakout season.

Getty Images

Manager Enzo Maresca praised Palmer for showing leadership in difficult moments, noting that his willingness to ask for the ball in the second half was a positive sign. Yet, the overall decline in his assists is not due to a reduction in his ability to create opportunities—Palmer actually leads the Premier League in chances created—but rather the failure of his teammates to convert those opportunities. This statistical nuance suggests that Palmer’s issue might not be an individual decline in performance, but rather a reflection of the surrounding team’s inefficiency in the final third. With 14 games remaining in the season, there is cautious optimism that if his teammates can capitalise on the chances he creates, Palmer could match or even surpass his previous season’s output.

Key Points

  • Decline in Direct Contributions:
    • Palmer has recorded eight goals (including two penalties) and only one assist in 17 league games since the October break.
  • Consistent Underlying Production:
    • When penalties are excluded, his goal rate per 90 minutes is almost identical to his breakout season.
    • His non-penalty expected goals (npxG) per 90 remains stable at around 0.4.
  • High Chance Creation:
    • Palmer has created 32 chances in an 11-game stretch, more than any other player in Europe’s top five leagues during that period.
    • The cumulative value of these chances equates to an expected four assists, yet his teammates have failed to convert.
  • Managerial Praise:
    • Enzo Maresca highlighted Palmer’s leadership and noted his efforts to get involved, particularly in the second half of games.
  • Team Efficiency Issues:
    • The drop in assists is attributed more to the lack of conversion by his teammates than a decline in Palmer’s creative abilities.
  • Future Prospects:
    • With 14 games remaining, there is a possibility for Palmer to match or exceed his previous season’s non-penalty goal tally if the team improves its finishing.
  • More On This Story

    More sources covering the same story appear below 👇  
    Photo Credit
    Adrian Dennis/AFP via Getty Images
    View original content
    Written by 
    Steve Worrell
    Steve, Co-founder of The 1905 Club, created the platform to provide honest, clickbait-free Chelsea FC content. He worked at Stamford Bridge from 2013 to 2016 with a Champions League sponsor. His first Chelsea match was a 1-0 win at Leeds in 2000, and his favourite was the epic 2012 Champions League game against Napoli.
    match report
    Live data provided by